Friday, September 4, 2009

Theft From School Gym Locker

unconstitutional. Hyperopia


After the summer break, I want to return as best they can be blog posts commenting one that causes us to debate Subjective Geographer. Talk about the possibility of recovering prior recourse of unconstitutionality, a former procedural possibility removed for good reason.

As you can guess, I am totally against the recovery of that resource, because, from my point of view, is contrary to the democratic functioning of English political system. Nothing more, nothing less. Because in our constitutional system is already sufficient mechanisms to protect political minorities as we recover one of which did not use nothing but trouble at the time.

In a state where there is effective separation of powers and coordination (as much right to say uneducated English), in which there are already procedures and channels for minorities represented in Parliament, other groups outside the popular representation and even the judiciary to exercise its disagreement with the legislative agenda of the parliamentary majority and the current government, excluding periodic elections, and where we have a room that acts as a guarantor power and safeguard the constitutional and negative legislator, the suspension on a "preventive" per se relevantísimas standards, the bloc of constitutionality, is only an obstacle to the Government and its executive action.

Imagine the situation: Some courts similar to those we have now, with a government that does not have an absolute majority, a tense and crispadora opposition, the Constitutional Court so bogged down by opposition and the vast amount of resources under a solve. The executive branch reform gets through LOREG of changing the electoral formula or other infra to improve the proportionality of the election results, which it does not favor the majority party in the opposition, to retirement when the square kilometers are better people . Then, using the previous action of unconstitutionality, the law, duly approved by Parliament, is suspended at the mercy of the activity of a High Court swamped it takes an average of seven years in elucidating important issues. What will they think voters represented by the majority of Members who have endorsed their vote this legislative program? Who enforces its discretion to whom?

Some may argue that such previous action prevents damage occurring disorders and as a result of the future declaration of unconstitutionality of the contested provision. It is perfectly possible, but that already exist a number of mechanisms, applied by judges and courts on the rest of the legal sources, and also by the Constitutional Court, as are the precautionary measures that are taken not by obligation or automatically; After a quick survey of the damage difficult or impossible to repair as a result of the implementation of the relevant standard. Adequate security, temporary and measurable, which is not contrary to the full introduction effects of laws that make up the Government's legislative agenda.

With a Constitutional Court as this, and irrational opposition routinely use each star standards of the majority coalition between Congress and the government, the prior of unconstitutionality, as it did in its day Fraga, would be a trap nonsense, a gag on government action that would prevent it from fulfilling its purpose: to change society it serves democratically.

Because one thing is to defend minorities and other governments to prevent. And when it comes to residual areas of law but as relevant as that covered by Law, that is already protected by reinforced majorities required to approve such standards.

0 comments:

Post a Comment