I want to start a series of posts to address the renewal of the third "Senate" of our Constitutional Court, with reference to the different attitudes of the contesting parties and other factors. I'll take the analysis from at least two points of view: From game theory and from a philosophical and legal perspective (so to speak, but I feel that the term is too big).
post I will not focus too much on defining
Game Theory, and would not know as it should and I do take up too much space. Just say it is an analytical model that allows us to see as a game, the behaviors of various actors around a complete event. It said that in this case, I'll just approach the game in terms of two actors (PP and PSOE), with different patterns of behavior, so doing the PP, I gather almost opposites. Thanks to Colomer's book I cite in the previous post is it possible that I can do.
from the beginning of the issue: The addresses of both parties decide after renovations boost different constitutional bodies, do the same with the CGPJ, cooperating for a common purpose, and proceed to the removal of judges proposed by the Senate. They are, therefore, 4 new judges to appoint him as under Title IX of the EC, with no consensus between both parties to achieve the required qualified majority in the Senate. We can, with this information, locate a point of balance in the distribution of two judges nominated by each group, more or less independent and more or less neutral. We ignore add that, given the attitude of the PP, the referral of names from the legislatures of the CCAA gets to the Senate at the moment, irrelevant.
could propose a more or less equally well, but, apparently seen, does not work: You put both of his rope two judges each, and so fresh. But the Socialist Party is not willing to accept in view of the candidates who are putting little suspicious so far (or Angel Luis Martin Rebollo Juanes, regardless of their ideas, not shown, back here, sympathy for the PSOE so that we do say that they are of his rope, ie, manageable). Nor does not renew the Tribunal, as it believes that such support be reduced jam (electoral and otherwise) and show a weak government.
The best way to address the issue will be to propose situations of interaction between both sticking to our information, and organize the most desired to least desired, numbered 4 (more) to 1 (least) for each of them. I repeat: The management I will do as I do the interpretation of the movements of PP, especially, and the PSOE. The interest of the PP seems that is not to renew the whole thing, because in a sense, you feel that this whole is more or less well, and in any case, hinder the legislature prefers a more subtle way than in the past VIII.
look at PP: The most desirable option would be the hypothetical situation in which the PP proposes two judges ultras, the PSOE proposed two neutral swallows (4). The following is not renewing the Court, where he has enough tricks, so that the PSOE would have to put up (3). The next would be to agree the "two neutral" with the PSOE, which would equal two (2). Of course, the last option would be to swallow two separatist proposing two neutral red (1). Let's look at
PSOE: Ideally, in absolute terms, the two liberals swallow PP (fiscal or faculty, if possible) proposing this two neutrals (
4 ). The next thing would be to agree the renewal putting 4 more or less impartial judges (3
). Another option, worse, would not renew the TC (2
). Finally, the worst would swallow two ultras of the PP and put two neutral (
1 ).
All situations, as we see, are reproduced in both games, so we can confront them in an array. Before, it is clear that we believe that the conduct involved two judges to "neutral" means working together (options 2 and 1 PP, options 3 and 1, PSOE), which symbolize a C in the matrix, examples being the opposite of selfishness, we noted with the E. Both are two options of behavior that can get out both parties in the negotiation. Let's see the result:
Given the figures from boxes top left and bottom right, cooperate with one of the two and the other selfish act would be a joke for one of them, something virtually impossible given the cessation of the process that this would lead, in some ways sought by PP: The PP cells never accept two judges to reach the full Senate and the PSOE candidate would not accept two ultras. Some differences of -3 that make it nearly impossible without making the cousin, no party will accept it against him.
The other two options involve the direct denial of PP in the case (what happens in the bottom left, this has not occurred) or the negotiation of the four neutral candidates putting names on the list out of the Nomination Committee of the House (upper right box). Both options are more balanced in theory, because the values \u200b\u200bof the two parties have a difference of -1.
But keep in mind a question: What is the pattern of behavior (ie, C or E) leading to a party at your best? In the case of PP, 4 is E and 3 is E. In the case of the PSOE,
4 is E and
3 is C. The PP has a regular pattern of behavior that gives the victory: The Selfishness. So, in choosing between the two semiequilibros that enables us to lower left boxes and top right, the PP will be planted, preferably with a good excuse.
could say that the outcome of the matrix is \u200b\u200ba consequence of my choice of situations and values \u200b\u200bof each party. Indeed. Therefore I will explain why my scores to the situations and the resulting patterns of behavior in view of the appointments made today: The first two are the most desirable for both, but practically impossible, as the last two . As opuestras (as seen in the matrix), both parties would block the renewal. The PP would prefer not to lock the TC because, before a new more neutral judges who now prefers to are. In contrast, the PSOE candidates prefer to renew with consensus, because if it breaks the operation will be as before, not better. But in any case, prefer to continue as is and wait for another more positive renewal ultras put up with the TC, hence not to renew is not your last option.
This is the theory. What practice? In my opinion, confirms the ordering of the preferences of the theory, and the results of the matrix: PP
If he puts Hernando Lopez and the TC , even now that the Socialist Party, made the appointments of Assemblies of the Autonomous Communities, as you can dribble,
will have achieved its best . Since the PSOE has not proposed ultras, lost even the chance to win by a landslide to the PP. Since they can not get
unanimity of the four judges with these candidates, the upper right box can be discounted
. The Socialist Party could not even put two Rojaz use in comparison, the proposals have been lights for now (not raised the option to remove at first). In conclusion: The PP has achieved its secondary objective: Abort
renovation operation, knowingly and without the slightest compunction.