Without going into depth on the subject, I define the right as a way regulation and settlement of disputes between different subjects . From my point of view, the most effective, which does not mean there are others. And its effectiveness lies in two factors: Being the result of a tacit agreement of wills and be, once conceived the agreement, binding on all. The first thing
much has been written. Just worth noting that both private law as public law governing relations that have been reached by agreement tacit or not, formed from the development of Constitutionalism decimonómico in continuing to make some legislative bodies elected by the people, the owner of that sovereignty, that power to be and do not obey any rules of a higher order, because there is no higher order than the voluntas populi, or, if wants to voluntae populorum .
The other guarantee is that it is obligatory, and that is compulsory there is no doubt that the guarantor of the obligation must have mechanisms to ensure its rigidity and compliance. For me, the latter mechanism must be violence, understood as Max Weber would say, as a monopoly of state power, which is nothing that guarantees compliance with the rules governing our society. It must be, to use the correct term, while coercive imperative.
But what happens when two states which have disputes? Given the principle of sovereignty above, from the point of view of equality of all state entities, must obey any other. And then, for the settlement of disputes, there is the war as a way of doing politics, of setting a panorama of international relations. Thus we have seen throughout the history of humanity, I do not think it takes to give any examples.
But with the development of the International Society for Contemporary, the use of force as a common mechanism in relationships International has been seeing reduced, for the right, namely the peaceful settlement of disputes between entities endowed with equal sovereignty . Public international law arises. Surge diplomacy, as we understand it today. And so we, step by step, until the United Nations Charter shows of the International Treaty (agreement between states, as in private law agreement is reached between individuals) who detests the war as a mode of relations among nations of our planet as endorses Article 2 of the Charter, in paragraphs 2 and 3, and rule, the exception becomes highly priced, considering lawful use in self defense or if authorized by the Security Council, the most important organ within the UN. There was one final factor to consider: The level of force used in response to a first attack should respect the principle of proportionality.
Well, this is the defense of Israel to kill people: Self-defense. Prostituting an action that should be a last resort and an exception, as did the U.S. several times, and laughing with the principle of proportionality of the action. Let us not confuse: Killing children in schools or leave without light and water to nearly one million people is not proportional and does not constitute an act of retaliation or self-defense. called genocide.
The solution is not violence. Go through the right, by diplomacy, politics. But when international standards are not capable of coercion of those who have to obey them, little can be done against barbarism.
PD: Visions and similar interesting blogs Ginel Alberto and Subjective Geographer, always interesting.
0 comments:
Post a Comment